Unlocking more STEM talent through transfer

iStock

Community colleges already play a major role in producing STEM graduates, but a new report suggests their contribution could be much larger if colleges and universities improve transfer pathways.

New research finds community college students are an underutilized source of STEM talent, with stronger transfer systems potentially adding more than 18,000 bachelor’s degree holders in science, technology, engineering and math fields.

The report, “Unlocking STEM Talent: What Happens to Transfer Students at the Four-Year College?,” from the Community College Research Center (CCRC) at Teachers College, Columbia University, found that community college transfer students account for nearly 56,000 STEM bachelor’s degree earners, representing 15% of all STEM bachelor’s graduates in the student cohort studied.

View state-by-state data on the data dashboard

Yet community college transfers are less likely than students who start at four-year institutions to complete a bachelor’s degree in a STEM field. Researchers estimate that if transfer students earned STEM degrees at the same rate as their non-transfer peers, more than 18,000 additional students would have graduated with STEM bachelor’s degrees.

“For transfer students, the path to a STEM bachelor’s degree is often harder than it needs to be,” said Tatiana Velasco, senior research associate at CCRC and lead author of the report. “Our report shows where students fall behind, even compared with transfer students in other fields, and what colleges and state systems can do to strengthen these pathways.”

Diving into the data

Using National Student Clearinghouse data, researchers examined students who entered four-year institutions in 2015-16 and completed bachelor’s degrees within six years. Among community college transfer bachelor’s graduates, 17% earned degrees in STEM, compared with 23% of students who started at four-year institutions. Only 16% of STEM transfer graduates completed a bachelor’s degree within four years of starting community college, compared with 20% of transfer students in non-STEM fields. Engineering students faced some of the longest delays.

Researchers found that STEM transfer students spent nearly five months longer at four-year institutions than their peers in non-STEM majors, suggesting obstacles emerge after transfer. Challenges can include misaligned course requirements, credit-transfer issues and limited access to required upper-level courses.

The study also found that Black, Hispanic and low-income students face the greatest hurdles along STEM transfer pathways. Women were less likely than other students to earn STEM bachelor’s degrees, though women who completed STEM degrees were more likely to finish on time and pursue graduate education.

Some states show what’s possible

The report highlights examples of stronger-performing states. Washington, Maryland and Colorado had the highest shares of STEM graduates among transfer bachelor’s recipients, while California and Florida also posted strong results on several measures. Washington, in particular, stood out for having a relatively small gap between transfer and non-transfer students earning STEM degrees.

Researchers argue that improving STEM transfer outcomes will require coordinated action from community colleges, universities and state systems. Among their recommendations:

  • Universities should better align STEM coursework with community college programs, ensure transfer students can immediately enter major course sequences, and expand access to undergraduate research and faculty mentorship.
  • Community colleges should help students become “major-ready” before transfer by completing the math and science courses required for their intended majors.
  • States should map statewide STEM pathways and use data to identify and close transfer gaps.

“As four-year colleges face growing pressure to expand the number of students pursuing STEM degrees, community colleges offer a largely untapped source of talent,” the report notes. “This new report highlights opportunities to increase STEM bachelor’s attainment and graduate enrollment while broadening socioeconomic and racial diversity.”

About the Author

Daily Staff
CCDaily is published by the American Association of Community Colleges.
The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.